top of page

Similarities and Differences

laurie597
Nov 5
3 min read

I have been thinking a lot about similarities and differences lately. No doubt that’s because we’re now living in our third country, and I’m that much more aware of how daily life involves finding what is familiar and what is new.


Let’s start with food. One of the more noticeable differences between grocery shopping in the United States and anywhere overseas is the cereal aisle. In the US, it goes on forever. Outside of the US, it’s a small fraction of the size. My kids were initially disappointed that many of their favorite cereals weren’t available, but it didn’t take much convincing that the selection of bread rolls could make up for any carb cravings. Our breakfast category just needed a little expanding. 

We do this constantly with new experiences: spot what’s similar, what’s different, and usually draw some kind of new understanding based on the comparisons. We’re continually stretching our categories and creating new ones. 


As speech-language pathologists, we spend a lot of time teaching young children to do this at a basic level. An apple and a banana are alike because they’re both fruit, but different in color, shape, and texture. It’s a key piece of vocabulary development, and it helps children label attributes and generally describe the world they see around them. 


I’m currently reading Surfaces and Essences by Douglas Hofstadter and Emmanuel Sander, who argue that categories underlie much of our thinking. Every new experience gets sorted by what it reminds us of, and the categories stretch to fit. My kids’ “hot chocolate” category took a hit at the fall festival, when the cup they were handed turned out to be unsweetened. They’ve since recovered.


While I’m over here recategorizing breakfast options, our middle and high school students are doing something harder: sorting ideas, not just fruits and breakfast foods. They’re expected to see that the American and French Revolutions belong in the same category (but not for all the same reasons), or that “balance” means something different in a chemistry equation, a civics unit on checks and balances, and the novel they’re reading in English. As the categories get more abstract, the features that connect things are less visible. This kind of category refinement and relational thinking keeps developing well into the teen years. If you’ve ever been stuck on NYT Connections, convinced four words belong together until one turns out to belong somewhere else, you’ve felt how hard it is to let go of a grouping that seemed right.


That’s the part we tend to forget. We teach similarities and differences early, then move on as if the skill is finished. It isn’t, and there are a lot of places it can break down through adolescence. You need enough vocabulary to name the features that connect things (and the category words that hold them together), plus the syntax to say it out loud, with words like “both,” “whereas,” and “unlike.” Working memory helps you hold several ideas in mind at once, and response inhibition helps you resist that first obvious match. 


Categorization is also closely linked to executive functioning, an area I work on a lot with my students. Planning, organizing, and reflecting all depend on sorting through a lot of information, and recognizing what one idea/task has in common with another. A student who sees that this week’s science lab is a similar kind of problem as last week’s history project can reuse the approach. A student who doesn’t, can easily become overwhelmed. 


That recognition, seeing that two different things share the same underlying structure, is what Hofstadter and Sander build upon when describing analogical thinking. It's the thread I’ll pick up in my next post: how analogies can help us talk with students about executive functioning and other language and learning topics. It’s been central to a project I’m working on, so I’m excited to share more.


 
 
bottom of page